Now that ESPN has updated the ESPN 300, I figured I'd do a quick Mills update. They still way undervalue Mills, but not by as much. He is now the #4 pocket passer (#8 QB overall) and the #82 recruit overall. That's at least within spitting distance of the other QBs.Â
To sum up:Â
- Scout: #1 QB/# 3 overall
- 247: #1 QB/#21 overall
- Rivals: #2 QB/#28 overall (behind Clemson commit Hunter Johnson, the #4 overall recruit)
- ESPN: #8 QB (#4 pocket passer)/#82 overall (behind Johnson, McCaffrey the Younger, Penn State's Sean Clifford, Alabama's Tua Tagovailoa, Texas A&M's Kellen Mond, LSU's Lowell Narcisse, and Miami's N'Kosi Perry
Appreciably less shameful than the last round of ESPN rankings, but still an outlier on QBs overall. Having him behind Johnson is fine--he's been one of the top QBs on all services for a long time, and they're both terrific. And Tagavailoa is hardly egregious, as all the services agree that he's a top guy and probably the top dual-threat guy out there (#3 QB/#34 overall on Scout, #3 QB-DT/#56 overall on Rivals, and #1 QB-DT/#34 overall on 247), so picking one over the other is like splitting hairs or whether you prefer a pro-style passer or a dual threat guy. And Dylan McCaffrey is generally a top 50 overall recruit (except for Scout, which has him at 101), so whatever.Â
But Clifford, for example, is the #7 pro-style QB on Rivals (#163 overall), the #10 pro-style QB on 247 (and #360 overall, just a 3 star), and the #18 QB on Scout (#245 overall). Narcisse is similar (#13 QB/#183 overall on Scout, #7 dual-threat QB/#250 overall on 247). So is Mond (#3 dual-threat QB/#172 overall on 247, #6 QB-DT/#101 overall on Rivals, #9 QB/#95 overall on Scout). So is Perry (#9 QB-DT/#319 overall on 247, #17 QB-DT on Rivals (doesn't even have an overall recruit ranking), and the #17 QB/#238 overall on Scout).Â