(05-19-2026, 07:20 AM)Hieronymus Wrote:(05-18-2026, 05:27 PM)Goose Wrote:(05-18-2026, 04:47 PM)qwerty49 Wrote: David Shaw lived off Jim Harbaugh’s legacy for pretty long, until he ran out of magic inspiration. Kate looks to be in the same position w/r/t Tara.Really? While I definitely take issue with the idea that David Shaw "lived off Jim Harbaugh's legacy" even if one accepts that argument Shaw was successful for 7 (at a minimum) of his 12 seasons and is the winningest coach in program history. Kate obviously has had no similar success in her two years as head coach at Stanford. Her situation is nothing at all like David Shaw.
Yeah this is pretty unfair to Shaw. I was firmly in the camp that Shaw stuck around 2-3 years too long as the decline became obvious. But at the same time, you can’t deny he was massively successful - and beyond just living off Harbaugh’s legacy. As noted, KP so far has no successes to claim in contrast. Next year is unlikely to change that fact, and I hope we don’t witness a year 4.
This is similar to how I see it. Harbaugh made the incredible, miraculous turnaround. But it was by no means guaranteed to be sustained. Shaw picked up that ball and carried it wildly successfully for years. Only at the end, last couple/few years did it peter out. For reasons perhaps some to his detriment, some outside his control with the changing landscape, for whatever the reasons, the "tunnel workers" or "intellectual brutality" was all gone and has been hard to recover. I am, in spite of many serious considerations and flaws heavily to the contrary, optimistic for this upcoming season. If not for total wins, at least for some more of the strong physical play we saw glimpses of last season.
Oh and to bring it back to the topic this thread is supposed to be about, WBB, I think comparing Coach KP to Coach DS is like comparing apples to oranges, with one of the fruits seeming a bit overripe and not that appetizing.

