[AlbanyCardinal]

I agree that the Goff-vs-Kline comparison is sui generis, but I think the sample size of true freshmen starting -- in a variety of different situations -- is high enough to conclude most true freshmen starting QBs stink, whatever the particular circumstances of this or that true freshman.

I agree with your general point, but I guess I'd also say that Kline would be thrown to the wolves in this case were he to start this season, given new coach and style of offense. There's an argument to be made that Goff maybe less so, not only b/c he's appeared more consistent/productive in practices (according to several cal fans) but b/c of his high school resume.

Regardless, could be a tough year for the bears given that they have arguably the toughest schedule in college football.

[AlbanyCardinal]

I agree that the Goff-vs-Kline comparison is sui generis, but I think the sample size of true freshmen starting -- in a variety of different situations -- is high enough to conclude most true freshmen starting QBs stink, whatever the particular circumstances of this or that true freshman.

I agree with your general point, but I guess I'd also say that Kline would be thrown to the wolves in this case were he to start this season, given new coach and style of offense. There's an argument to be made that Goff maybe less so, not only b/c he's appeared more consistent/productive in practices (according to several cal fans) but b/c of his high school resume.

Regardless, could be a tough year for the bears given that they have arguably the toughest schedule in college football.