[BobK]

Without peeking lol

Name the SF Giants who have won Cy Young with the Giants

Name the future or past SF Giants who won the Cy Young with another team.

[BobK]

Without peeking lol

Name the SF Giants who have won Cy Young with the Giants

Name the future or past SF Giants who won the Cy Young with another team.

[81alum]

Isn't the Cy Young a pretty recent award?  So Christy Matthewson would not have been eligible....?

[81alum]

Isn't the Cy Young a pretty recent award?  So Christy Matthewson would not have been eligible....?

[BobK]

Well Christy never pitched in SF and the award is older than you my friend.  Lol.  The question is for SF Giants

[BobK]

Well Christy never pitched in SF and the award is older than you my friend.  Lol.  The question is for SF Giants

[82lsju]

>> Name the SF Giants who have won Cy Young with the Giants

well the easy answer is Lincecum but there most be at least one more......

[82lsju]

>> Name the SF Giants who have won Cy Young with the Giants

well the easy answer is Lincecum but there most be at least one more......

[BobK]

Timmy twice and one more won as a Giant. 

[BobK]

Timmy twice and one more won as a Giant. 

[Robbie]

Marichal?

[Robbie]

Marichal?

[BobK]

Not Juan

[BobK]

Not Juan

[DC 86]

Mike McCormick.

Gaylord Perry a Giant who won the award elsewhere.

[DC 86]

Mike McCormick.

Gaylord Perry a Giant who won the award elsewhere.

[82lsju]

>> Name the future or past SF Giants who won the Cy Young with another team.

Steve Carlton would be one

Vida Blue would be another if winning in the AL counts for this question

[82lsju]

>> Name the future or past SF Giants who won the Cy Young with another team.

Steve Carlton would be one

Vida Blue would be another if winning in the AL counts for this question

[BobK]

Yes on McCormick. 

Now 10 future or past SF Giants who  won on other teams
Yes on
Blue
Carllton
Perry who won with two different teams. 
7 to go

[BobK]

Yes on McCormick. 

Now 10 future or past SF Giants who  won on other teams
Yes on
Blue
Carllton
Perry who won with two different teams. 
7 to go

[qwerty49]

Zito.

I'm going to guess Peavy...and Warren Spahn?

I can't recall any other washed up veterans they acquired.

[qwerty49]

Zito.

I'm going to guess Peavy...and Warren Spahn?

I can't recall any other washed up veterans they acquired.

[Phogge]

Mark Davis, Steve Stone.

[Phogge]

Mark Davis, Steve Stone.

[Phogge]

Randy Johnson. The other has to be a late season reliever for a pennant run. Mota, or the tall guy from the Wilson Alvarez trade whose name I can't remember or Bedrosian. If I have to choose I'd guess the Armenian.

[Phogge]

Randy Johnson. The other has to be a late season reliever for a pennant run. Mota, or the tall guy from the Wilson Alvarez trade whose name I can't remember or Bedrosian. If I have to choose I'd guess the Armenian.

[Mick]

Without looking and not repeating the names listed before, my guesses would include Orel Hershiser and Warren Spahn.

I don't think any of the relievers won the Cy Young (Bedrosian, Wilson, ), and I don't think Ron Bryant won the Cy Young when he won 24 games.  I don't think Burkett, Schmidt or Swift won, or Reuschel or Krukow.

[Mick]

Without looking and not repeating the names listed before, my guesses would include Orel Hershiser and Warren Spahn.

I don't think any of the relievers won the Cy Young (Bedrosian, Wilson, ), and I don't think Ron Bryant won the Cy Young when he won 24 games.  I don't think Burkett, Schmidt or Swift won, or Reuschel or Krukow.

[Mick]

Without looking and not repeating the names listed before, my guesses would include Orel Hershiser and Warren Spahn.

I don't think any of the relievers won the Cy Young (Bedrosian, Wilson, ), and I don't think Ron Bryant won the Cy Young when he won 24 games.  I don't think Burkett, Schmidt or Swift won, or Reuschel or Krukow.

I was right about Hershiser and Spahn.  Wrong about Bedrosian, he won the Cy Young award.

The SF Giant starters who did not win the Cy Young -- Ron Bryant, John Burkett, Mike Krukow, Bill Swift, Jason Schmidt and Rick Reuschel all have something in common vis-a-vis the Cy Young award.  Every one of them had a higher winning percentage than the pitcher who won the award that year.

[Mick]

Without looking and not repeating the names listed before, my guesses would include Orel Hershiser and Warren Spahn.

I don't think any of the relievers won the Cy Young (Bedrosian, Wilson, ), and I don't think Ron Bryant won the Cy Young when he won 24 games.  I don't think Burkett, Schmidt or Swift won, or Reuschel or Krukow.

I was right about Hershiser and Spahn.  Wrong about Bedrosian, he won the Cy Young award.

The SF Giant starters who did not win the Cy Young -- Ron Bryant, John Burkett, Mike Krukow, Bill Swift, Jason Schmidt and Rick Reuschel all have something in common vis-a-vis the Cy Young award.  Every one of them had a higher winning percentage than the pitcher who won the award that year.

[Phogge]

McCormick
Timmy
Perry
Carlton
Orel
Stone
Davis
Johnson
Peavy
Spahn
Bedrosian
Blue

Who got the only hit off Juan to spoil his first rookie game with the Giants. Note: complete game.

[Phogge]

McCormick
Timmy
Perry
Carlton
Orel
Stone
Davis
Johnson
Peavy
Spahn
Bedrosian
Blue

Who got the only hit off Juan to spoil his first rookie game with the Giants. Note: complete game.

[BobK]

Davis and Stone certainly weren't washed up when traded. 
I'll post shortly but all have been named.  No not Orel.

[BobK]

Davis and Stone certainly weren't washed up when traded. 
I'll post shortly but all have been named.  No not Orel.

[Mick]

Davis and Stone certainly weren't washed up when traded. 
I'll post shortly but all have been named.  No not Orel.

Orel won the 1988 NL Cy Young Award.  I was wrong on Bedrosian.

Davis definitely wasn't washed up.  He had some grim years as a starter for the Giants earlier in his career, then they moved him to long relief.  He left the Giants at age 26 for the Padres, went to the All Star game when he was 27 and 28, with 72 saves between those two years.  He went south fast after that, with just 15 more saves, 20 starts and a 14-27 record in the next eight years.

Stone was 11-17 for the Giants his first two years of his career (though his second year was a vast improvement), but he really only had one great season, his Cy Young season when he went 25-7 in 1980 as a 32 year old.  He went 4-7 the year after that, then retired.  He sure got traded a lot -- five teams in 11 years.  Stone was thoughtful and intelligent, Kent State grad, and his first manager, Charlie Fox was...not.  Funny bit of trivia, Stone gave up Duane Kuiper's only home run.

[Mick]

Davis and Stone certainly weren't washed up when traded. 
I'll post shortly but all have been named.  No not Orel.

Orel won the 1988 NL Cy Young Award.  I was wrong on Bedrosian.

Davis definitely wasn't washed up.  He had some grim years as a starter for the Giants earlier in his career, then they moved him to long relief.  He left the Giants at age 26 for the Padres, went to the All Star game when he was 27 and 28, with 72 saves between those two years.  He went south fast after that, with just 15 more saves, 20 starts and a 14-27 record in the next eight years.

Stone was 11-17 for the Giants his first two years of his career (though his second year was a vast improvement), but he really only had one great season, his Cy Young season when he went 25-7 in 1980 as a 32 year old.  He went 4-7 the year after that, then retired.  He sure got traded a lot -- five teams in 11 years.  Stone was thoughtful and intelligent, Kent State grad, and his first manager, Charlie Fox was...not.  Funny bit of trivia, Stone gave up Duane Kuiper's only home run.

[BobK]

Spahn
McCormick
Charlton
Perry
Bedrosian
Mark Davis
Randy Johnson
Jake Peavy
Timmy
Vida Blue
Steve Stone
Barry Zito

and son of a gun Orel was 11-10 in one year with the Giants.  Nice Mick. 

[BobK]

Spahn
McCormick
Charlton
Perry
Bedrosian
Mark Davis
Randy Johnson
Jake Peavy
Timmy
Vida Blue
Steve Stone
Barry Zito

and son of a gun Orel was 11-10 in one year with the Giants.  Nice Mick.