[Stymie]

[quote author=Redrum link=topic=11016.msg103850#msg103850 date=1414601882]
What it boils down to is we are not winning like we used to and the hunt for the guilty is on.

I dunno, lots of people were on open season preemptively over the years. Not that that matters for this particular discussion, just an observation.

Anyway, I'm not sure the Innovator's Dilemma is the best cite here for someone advocating David Shaw adjustments. One persuasive reading of that book is that old institutions cannot change; they are replaced.
[/quote]

I think the Prisoner's Dilemma is more relevant, if we apply some subtle variations.  What frustrates many of us is that the coaching staff often seems to think they are not guilty of stereotypical and blunt offensive strategies, and worse think that if they continue to scheme within those stereotypes (e.g. Power) something good will come of it even though their opponents increasingly know what they are doing and can strategise against them successfully.  While Tit for Tat tends to win the simple Prisoner's Dilemma game, football is a far more complex endeavor, which values controlled uncertainty over pure execution.

[Stymie]

[quote author=Redrum link=topic=11016.msg103850#msg103850 date=1414601882]
What it boils down to is we are not winning like we used to and the hunt for the guilty is on.

I dunno, lots of people were on open season preemptively over the years. Not that that matters for this particular discussion, just an observation.

Anyway, I'm not sure the Innovator's Dilemma is the best cite here for someone advocating David Shaw adjustments. One persuasive reading of that book is that old institutions cannot change; they are replaced.
[/quote]

I think the Prisoner's Dilemma is more relevant, if we apply some subtle variations.  What frustrates many of us is that the coaching staff often seems to think they are not guilty of stereotypical and blunt offensive strategies, and worse think that if they continue to scheme within those stereotypes (e.g. Power) something good will come of it even though their opponents increasingly know what they are doing and can strategise against them successfully.  While Tit for Tat tends to win the simple Prisoner's Dilemma game, football is a far more complex endeavor, which values controlled uncertainty over pure execution.