10-23-2014, 09:49 PM
I think I saw a comment in another thread, but statistically, when was Hogan at his best? Yes, it's somewhat subjective, but the QBR rating of last week and the year is not stellar. The reality is that we are now passing more than in the past, which means there is more pressure on our QB to make completions.  I'm guessing you would say his peak was 2013?
Garvin, you don't have to go back that far (Stenstrom and Palumbus) as I'm sure you are well aware. Many were calling for Hogan or "the Sheriff" to get some snaps versus Nunes when he started to fall off.  I was one of them and I'm glad that choice was made by the staff.  Do I think Shaw has the best data to make this decision? Yes. Do I think he can sometimes be stubborn to a fault with play calling and personnel and place kickers? Yes.   Am I glad he's our coach? Absolutely!
Garvin, you don't have to go back that far (Stenstrom and Palumbus) as I'm sure you are well aware. Many were calling for Hogan or "the Sheriff" to get some snaps versus Nunes when he started to fall off.  I was one of them and I'm glad that choice was made by the staff.  Do I think Shaw has the best data to make this decision? Yes. Do I think he can sometimes be stubborn to a fault with play calling and personnel and place kickers? Yes.   Am I glad he's our coach? Absolutely!