[Mick]

I think there is evidence he has done at least a pretty good job as a QB coach.

I don’t know, is there? McKee kind of underperformed this year and QB recruiting has been rather underwhelming.  That could all be laid at Shaw’s doorstep, but it hardly qualifies as evidence that Pritchard “has done at least a pretty good job as QB coach.”

BC

Tbf he has been involved in coaching 2 QBs who have NFL starts and another who is a mid round prospect.

People have suggested that we have had several quarterbacks who have underachieved based on their rankings coming out of high school.
So I guess you can make arguments either way.

It's not as if the backs, receivers, TEs and OLs covered themselves in glory. Lots of arguments to be made as to which coach/coordinator was most responsible and which should (not) be re-hired. Looks like TP fit the bill. He's ex-Stanford and a pretty good recruiter, if memory serves.

[Mick]

I think there is evidence he has done at least a pretty good job as a QB coach.

I don’t know, is there? McKee kind of underperformed this year and QB recruiting has been rather underwhelming.  That could all be laid at Shaw’s doorstep, but it hardly qualifies as evidence that Pritchard “has done at least a pretty good job as QB coach.”

BC

Tbf he has been involved in coaching 2 QBs who have NFL starts and another who is a mid round prospect.

People have suggested that we have had several quarterbacks who have underachieved based on their rankings coming out of high school.
So I guess you can make arguments either way.

It's not as if the backs, receivers, TEs and OLs covered themselves in glory. Lots of arguments to be made as to which coach/coordinator was most responsible and which should (not) be re-hired. Looks like TP fit the bill. He's ex-Stanford and a pretty good recruiter, if memory serves.