[Mick]

Not really a trivia question, but in keeping with the NFL trivia, here's my All-Time, All-NFL, team of the best players that are not in the NFL Hall of Fame:

QB   Ken Anderson (4 pro bowls).
RB   Roger Craig (4 pro bowls, first player in NFL to have 1,000 yards rushing and receiving the same season)
RB   Rickey "For Who? For What?" Watters (5 pro bowls). 
WR  Torry Holt (7 pro bowls)
WR  Reggie Wayne (6 pro bowls)
TE   Brent Jones (4 pro bowls)
OT   Mike Kenn (5 pro bowls)
OT   Jim Tyrer (9 pro bowls)
C Jay Hilgenberg (7 pro bowls)
OG  Steve Wisniewski (8 pro bowls)
OG  Walt Sweeney (9 pro bowls)
OG  Ed Budde (7 pro bowls)

DT  Steve McMichael (two all pros, 92.5 career sacks)
DT  Roger Brown (6 all pros)
DE  L.C. Greenwood (6 pro bowls)
DE  Jim Marshall (just 2 pro bowls, but 20 years on the DL)
LB   Randy Gradishar (7 pro bowls)
LB   Zach Thomas (7 pro bowls)
LB   Chuck Howley (6 pro bowls)
LB   Maxie Baughan (9 pro bowls)
CB  Lester Hayes (5 pro bowls)
CB  Lamar Parrish (8 pro bowls.
CB  Ken Riley (65 INTs, #5 all time)
S    Darren Woodson (5 pro bowls)
S    Johnny Robinson (7 pro bowls)
ST  Steve Tasker, 7 pro bowls for special teams

HM for Lee Roy Jordan (5 pro bowls)Hines Ward (4 pro bowls) and WR Sterling Sharpe and LB Patrick Willis for careers cut short. Lots of WRs with 2-5 pro bowls, including John Taylor, Billy White Shoes Johnson, Sterling Sharpe, Henry Ellard, Herman Moore, and Gino Cappelletti. Other QBs who have 4 pro bowls but aren't in the HoF include Randall Cunningham, Esiason, Bledsoe. HM to RBs Cookie Gilchrist and Larry Brown who had four pro bowls each, HM OT Joe Jacoby (4 pro bowls).

[Mick]

Not really a trivia question, but in keeping with the NFL trivia, here's my All-Time, All-NFL, team of the best players that are not in the NFL Hall of Fame:

QB   Ken Anderson (4 pro bowls).
RB   Roger Craig (4 pro bowls, first player in NFL to have 1,000 yards rushing and receiving the same season)
RB   Rickey "For Who? For What?" Watters (5 pro bowls). 
WR  Torry Holt (7 pro bowls)
WR  Reggie Wayne (6 pro bowls)
TE   Brent Jones (4 pro bowls)
OT   Mike Kenn (5 pro bowls)
OT   Jim Tyrer (9 pro bowls)
C Jay Hilgenberg (7 pro bowls)
OG  Steve Wisniewski (8 pro bowls)
OG  Walt Sweeney (9 pro bowls)
OG  Ed Budde (7 pro bowls)

DT  Steve McMichael (two all pros, 92.5 career sacks)
DT  Roger Brown (6 all pros)
DE  L.C. Greenwood (6 pro bowls)
DE  Jim Marshall (just 2 pro bowls, but 20 years on the DL)
LB   Randy Gradishar (7 pro bowls)
LB   Zach Thomas (7 pro bowls)
LB   Chuck Howley (6 pro bowls)
LB   Maxie Baughan (9 pro bowls)
CB  Lester Hayes (5 pro bowls)
CB  Lamar Parrish (8 pro bowls.
CB  Ken Riley (65 INTs, #5 all time)
S    Darren Woodson (5 pro bowls)
S    Johnny Robinson (7 pro bowls)
ST  Steve Tasker, 7 pro bowls for special teams

HM for Lee Roy Jordan (5 pro bowls)Hines Ward (4 pro bowls) and WR Sterling Sharpe and LB Patrick Willis for careers cut short. Lots of WRs with 2-5 pro bowls, including John Taylor, Billy White Shoes Johnson, Sterling Sharpe, Henry Ellard, Herman Moore, and Gino Cappelletti. Other QBs who have 4 pro bowls but aren't in the HoF include Randall Cunningham, Esiason, Bledsoe. HM to RBs Cookie Gilchrist and Larry Brown who had four pro bowls each, HM OT Joe Jacoby (4 pro bowls).