[Mick]

I think we can use this model as a primer on how Zaidi will function with the Giants - don’t look for significant dollar/years contracts unless the player is an exception to the rule.

Ironically, that was the only real issue I'd ever had with Farhan, which was his (borderline nonsensical) pursuit of Bryce Harper.  Harper is exactly where he should be, in Philly's bandbox of a park.  Historically speaking, Harper did better in Philadelphia than anywhere else and did worst at AT&T in SF but Farhan offered Harper 12 years at $310 million.  That was a terrible deal, I thought.  Sure, he's doing well in Philly (1.103 in 2021) and not-so-great at oracle (.697).  Harper's career-best OPS at ballparks where he's had at least 100 plate appearances (13 ballparks) is at Coors field (1.107), then Wrigley (1.053), then Philadelphia/Citizen's Bank (.999).  His worst OPS is still at AT&T (.669).

[Mick]

I think we can use this model as a primer on how Zaidi will function with the Giants - don’t look for significant dollar/years contracts unless the player is an exception to the rule.

Ironically, that was the only real issue I'd ever had with Farhan, which was his (borderline nonsensical) pursuit of Bryce Harper.  Harper is exactly where he should be, in Philly's bandbox of a park.  Historically speaking, Harper did better in Philadelphia than anywhere else and did worst at AT&T in SF but Farhan offered Harper 12 years at $310 million.  That was a terrible deal, I thought.  Sure, he's doing well in Philly (1.103 in 2021) and not-so-great at oracle (.697).  Harper's career-best OPS at ballparks where he's had at least 100 plate appearances (13 ballparks) is at Coors field (1.107), then Wrigley (1.053), then Philadelphia/Citizen's Bank (.999).  His worst OPS is still at AT&T (.669).