[DC 86]

Ok I looked at a list.  But still guessing Ben Chapman

I screwed up this question, so I am going to retract it. After you answered I looked it up and realized that there were several non-hall of famers in that first all star game (1932). I had always heard the question being related to Wally Berger and it appears it was the 1934 game which featured 17 future hall of famers in the starting lineup as well as Berger. My bad.

[DC 86]

Ok I looked at a list.  But still guessing Ben Chapman

I screwed up this question, so I am going to retract it. After you answered I looked it up and realized that there were several non-hall of famers in that first all star game (1932). I had always heard the question being related to Wally Berger and it appears it was the 1934 game which featured 17 future hall of famers in the starting lineup as well as Berger. My bad.