[stupac2]

Anyway, what he did four years ago doesn't matter if he can't do it today.

I know this isn't exactly relevant what you're trying to say, but it's worth noting that many football observers (including Bill Walsh, IIRC) consider accuracy to be innate. As in, once you get to a certain point, a guy either has it or he doesn't. I believe what WiM is saying is that Chryst demonstrably doesn't have it.

(I'd be interested to see if this is true, I can think of a few instance of guys increasing their completion percentage in the NFL, but of course you have to control for the types of throws and that's usually what does it.)

[stupac2]

Anyway, what he did four years ago doesn't matter if he can't do it today.

I know this isn't exactly relevant what you're trying to say, but it's worth noting that many football observers (including Bill Walsh, IIRC) consider accuracy to be innate. As in, once you get to a certain point, a guy either has it or he doesn't. I believe what WiM is saying is that Chryst demonstrably doesn't have it.

(I'd be interested to see if this is true, I can think of a few instance of guys increasing their completion percentage in the NFL, but of course you have to control for the types of throws and that's usually what does it.)