Putting guys in the NFL is different from having success in the NFL.
I did mention Miami, specifically Kelly and Testaverde. You could add Kosar as Miami's #3 guy. But QBs like Dorsey, Toretta, Walsh, and Erickson didn't have success as pro players. Mira was a career back-up, as I recall.
Washington has had one guy with a pro career comparable to the careers of the guys on Stanford's list -- Moon. You could put Brunell and Chandler on UW's list, as they were starters for a significant time. But that's it for them.
All five of the guys on Stanford's list had good, long, successful pro careers as starting QBs. (Well, Luck's career isn't long yet, but with 3 Pro Bowls in 3 years, he obviously belongs on the list.) I don't think anyone else can match the track record of Stanford's top 5.
I did mention Miami, specifically Kelly and Testaverde. You could add Kosar as Miami's #3 guy. But QBs like Dorsey, Toretta, Walsh, and Erickson didn't have success as pro players. Mira was a career back-up, as I recall.
Washington has had one guy with a pro career comparable to the careers of the guys on Stanford's list -- Moon. You could put Brunell and Chandler on UW's list, as they were starters for a significant time. But that's it for them.
All five of the guys on Stanford's list had good, long, successful pro careers as starting QBs. (Well, Luck's career isn't long yet, but with 3 Pro Bowls in 3 years, he obviously belongs on the list.) I don't think anyone else can match the track record of Stanford's top 5.