12-01-2021, 05:15 PM
(12-01-2021, 03:59 PM)lex24 Wrote:(12-01-2021, 02:00 PM)Giants Wrote:(12-01-2021, 01:15 PM)BobK Wrote: Wood signing announced. 2 years $ 25M.
I like the two year term. So far, Zaidi has done a nice job of signing guys to reasonable contracts. I agree with Phogge re: a RH OF with power (a very good one will cause Zaidi to go outside his financial comfort zone) and a couple more starters, giving SF some wiggle room when one needs some downtime.
It’s not Zaidi’s money. It his budget. Whatever that may be. If the Giants are going to pretend that they can’t compete money wise, then last year will be an aberration. They have lost Posey and Bryant. They are woefully short of right handed bats. Longer term contracts for hitters have less risk than for pitchers. If they are going to insist that they won’t go over 3 or 4 years, then im not particularly optimistic moving forward. Fortunately, im relatively confident that Zaidi won’t be inflexible.
Again, the Dodgers are the model. Build farm system (check). Find diamonds in the rough (check) AND when the opportunity strikes to sign an occasional whale, do it. (Giants haven’t checked that box).
The Giants should have a very large budget. At or near whatever the figure is they determine for a luxury tax. They are a top 5 team value wise.
Finally, long term contracts may not always pan out as you hope. But you can’t only evaluate on numbers. Zito is a great example. Bad deal. Right? Yet Giants don’t win in ‘12 without him. From an organizational standpoint, that alone made the deal worthwhile.
Agree with you Lex. But this last year was just surreal, almost as if it existed in some alternate universe. We got incredible mileage out of a roster that subjectively felt and seemed a bit above average but certainly not a pennant winner. A career year from Crawford, some streaky pitching at the right time, a nice find in Doval, and a nice stretch run that kept LA at bay until the end. Whoda thunk 107 wins back in April? It's hard to separate how much of that was due to Farhan's personnel moves, how much was longball improvement due to altered swing angles, and how much was just the way the ball bounced. I don't think the analytics guys can say 2021 was statistically pre-ordained.
I don't think anyone believes the Giants can just stand pat. But I know nothing. I never thought Crawford was a cleanup hitter and I was wrong last year. I never thought much of Belt as a clutch hitter and I was wrong last year, boy did we miss him down the stretch. I don't really think we have an everyday CF. Or an everyday C for that matter. Middle relief is traditionally a parking lot for 'tweeners, but hopefully Doval can be solid as an 8th or 9th inning closer and we can invest in a decent starter (I wasn't impressed by what little I saw of DeSciafani).
A side note: I wonder if "starters" are a dying breed. Back in the day you got 6-7 innings out of them. Now that seems to be the exception rather than the rule.
