Interesting stat -
washingtonismoney - 09-22-2017
Per Bill Connelly, it seems former five-star QBs only went 44-39 in 2015-16:
https://twitter.com/sbn_billc/status/911216313523212288
Some of it isn't the QBs' fault per se. I know Josh Rosen, for example, is a polarizing figure; but surely we can agree his modest record as a starter isn't entirely or even mostly his fault.
Still, the stat may indicate that a star QB recruit is less valuable than you'd think.