Good Argument Can Be Made For Giving QB Job to Costello At This Point of Season - Printable Version
+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Good Argument Can Be Made For Giving QB Job to Costello At This Point of Season (/thread-14306.html)
+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Good Argument Can Be Made For Giving QB Job to Costello At This Point of Season (/thread-14306.html)
Re: Good Argument Can Be Made For Giving QB Job to Costello At This Point of Season - fullmetal - 09-21-2017
Still haven't seen the game, but I did see the Instagram highlight reel of Bryce Love's runs that Stanford Football posted...
WTF was Chryst thinking on Love's 3Q 7:23 run?? Chryst *got in Love's way* causing Love to slow down/stumble/get tackled. I mean, DON'T GET IN YOUR RB'S WAY. Sure, you want to look good blocking, but causing him to slow down and get tackled is not how you do it.
Re: Good Argument Can Be Made For Giving QB Job to Costello At This Point of Season - BostonCard - 09-21-2017
(09-21-2017, 05:02 AM)JPRI link Wrote:On that final play against SDSU it seemed to me that JJ was well covered and Chryst just put the ball up there, hoping something good would happen. Obviously, it didn't.
He was pretty well covered, but it was single coverage by a defender who gave up 4-6 inches to him. It should have been a completed pass, or at the worst an incomplete pass where the DB makes a nice play to pry it loose from Arcega-Whiteside's grip. But it was badly underthrown (or the route was run incorrectly, which I guess is also a possibility) and only the DB could make a play on it.
BC
Re: Good Argument Can Be Made For Giving QB Job to Costello At This Point of Season - Spiny_Norman - 09-21-2017
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_e6R5RsxRNs
From this week's Bootleg podcast:
Keller Chryst has the 3 least efficient passing games of the Shaw-Harbaugh era (in terms of yards per attempt) - Arizona, OSU, SDSU. In fact SDSU was the worst Stanford passing game since 2006. Chryst's efficiency is trending down.
Chryst's passer rating vs SDSU was 30 points worse than the worst Josh Nunes game (2012 vs UW). His passer rating was worse than any of Burns' games as a starter.
But they don't totally blame Chryst. The discussion indicts the coaches more. Sam, RJ and David don't totally advocate a change to Costello because they are not confident of his success in this offense.
Re: I Started This Thread and Agree With Many Different Posters; To Wit - winflop - 09-21-2017
(09-20-2017, 09:25 PM)csfoster link Wrote:[quote author=AncientCityIndian link=topic=17413.msg201738#msg201738 date=1505959342]
1:Â We may be in a down year and Chryst may not be 100% and the OL is a work in progress
2:Â Costello just might be the right choice to get some hands on experience at this point in time
3:Â Next year may be a once in a decade chance to go into the playoffs and an experienced Costello may have the highest ceiling and our best chance to succeed.
I have faith in Chryst!
[/quote]
You may not if you listen to the Lombardi/Abetiya/Fisher podcast. The THREE worst QB performances (based on YPA) of the last 10 years ALL belong to Chryst. Not Nunes. Not Hogan (year 1). Not Burns. Not Nottingham.
Re: Good Argument Can Be Made For Giving QB Job to Costello At This Point of Season - CTcard - 09-22-2017
(09-21-2017, 02:01 PM)Boston Card link Wrote:[quote author=JPRI link=topic=17413.msg201747#msg201747 date=1505995326]
On that final play against SDSU it seemed to me that JJ was well covered and Chryst just put the ball up there, hoping something good would happen. Obviously, it didn't.
He was pretty well covered, but it was single coverage by a defender who gave up 4-6 inches to him. It should have been a completed pass, or at the worst an incomplete pass where the DB makes a nice play to pry it loose from Arcega-Whiteside's grip. But it was badly underthrown (or the route was run incorrectly, which I guess is also a possibility) and only the DB could make a play on it.
BC
[/quote]
Chryst threw that ball off his back foot, and he didn't have to as there was not tremendous pressure.
The pass was underthrown and thrown towards the middle of the field. That pass has to be to the sideline.
It was a similar error to the one Rosen made against us when Holder(?) picked it off and went for six in the play that got us going in 2015.
Re: Good Argument Can Be Made For Giving QB Job to Costello At This Point of Season - SamuelMcF - 09-22-2017
(09-22-2017, 12:33 PM)CTcard link Wrote:Holder(?)
Yep, Holder.