Bernard Muir to Resign - Printable Version
+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Bernard Muir to Resign (/thread-25485.html)
+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Bernard Muir to Resign (/thread-25485.html)
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - cctop - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 12:58 PM)paloalto Wrote: To say some other AD would have gotten Stanford into the B1G or the SEC, give me a break.
Yes but Stanford might have been more attractive to the B1G if a proactive AD had stepped in sooner when it became obvious that football was declining.
It's hard to imagine Stanford wouldn't have gotten (or been able to negotiate) a B1G invite if the Pac-12 had collapsed in 2018 instead of 2023.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - Spiny_Norman - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 01:00 PM)cardcrimson Wrote:(02-25-2025, 12:51 PM)paloalto Wrote: To be fair there are some good things happening right now in women's sports:
Softball team beat #1 Texas.
Beach Volleyball team beat #1 USC.
Women's Lacross team beat #7 Virginia. First time Lacross has ever beaten Virginia.
Women's golf recently won a tournament by about 38 stokes. The freshman recruits and next year's recruits are off the chart good.
Women's volleyball team is doing exceptionally well in recruiting for the next two years.
What? No mention of women's water polo? Currently #1, and handling #2 U$C 10-6 and crushing #3 UCLA 14-4 last weekend!
Stanford has about 4 teams that could continue the consecutive NC streak - WWP, women's golf, men's gymnastics, women's rowing. That's about it. No one else really close.
Women's water polo looks very good right now, with the return of 5 players who took last year off to train for the Olympics.
Men's gymnastics is the 5 time returning NCAA champ. Currently ranked #2.
Women's golf has won 2 of the last 3 NCs. Currently ranked #2.
Rowing has finished 2nd at NCAAs three of the last four years. They won the other year. Season begins in about a month.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - Mick - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 01:58 PM)Spiny_Norman Wrote:(02-25-2025, 01:00 PM)cardcrimson Wrote:(02-25-2025, 12:51 PM)paloalto Wrote: To be fair there are some good things happening right now in women's sports:
Softball team beat #1 Texas.
Beach Volleyball team beat #1 USC.
Women's Lacross team beat #7 Virginia. First time Lacross has ever beaten Virginia.
Women's golf recently won a tournament by about 38 stokes. The freshman recruits and next year's recruits are off the chart good.
Women's volleyball team is doing exceptionally well in recruiting for the next two years.
What? No mention of women's water polo? Currently #1, and handling #2 U$C 10-6 and crushing #3 UCLA 14-4 last weekend!
Stanford has about 4 teams that could continue the consecutive NC streak - WWP, women's golf, men's gymnastics, women's rowing. That's about it. No one else really close.
Women's water polo looks very good right now, with the return of 5 players who took last year off to train for the Olympics.
Men's gymnastics is the 5 time returning NCAA champ. Currently ranked #2.
Women's golf has won 2 of the last 3 NCs. Currently ranked #2.
Rowing has finished 2nd at NCAAs three of the last four years. They won the other year. Season begins in about a month.
The rest are long shots. I think baseball is a possibility. MVB next year (not this year). Men's swimming is #10.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - Jamesy - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 01:58 PM)Spiny_Norman Wrote:(02-25-2025, 01:00 PM)cardcrimson Wrote:(02-25-2025, 12:51 PM)paloalto Wrote: To be fair there are some good things happening right now in women's sports:
Softball team beat #1 Texas.
Beach Volleyball team beat #1 USC.
Women's Lacross team beat #7 Virginia. First time Lacross has ever beaten Virginia.
Women's golf recently won a tournament by about 38 stokes. The freshman recruits and next year's recruits are off the chart good.
Women's volleyball team is doing exceptionally well in recruiting for the next two years.
What? No mention of women's water polo? Currently #1, and handling #2 U$C 10-6 and crushing #3 UCLA 14-4 last weekend!
Stanford has about 4 teams that could continue the consecutive NC streak - WWP, women's golf, men's gymnastics, women's rowing. That's about it. No one else really close.
Women's water polo looks very good right now, with the return of 5 players who took last year off to train for the Olympics.
Men's gymnastics is the 5 time returning NCAA champ. Currently ranked #2.
Women's golf has won 2 of the last 3 NCs. Currently ranked #2.
Rowing has finished 2nd at NCAAs three of the last four years. They won the other year. Season begins in about a month.
Agreed, WWP the most likely team to win a title for Stanford this year. Men's gym has had a dominant run, but they are not looking as good this season, with losses to tOSU and Oklahoma. If we can get fully healthy for NCAAs, we're good, but it's a big if.
If women's golf was pure stroke play, I'd say we're a large favorite. Match play makes for some unpredictability though Walker has been good for us in this format.
Women's rowing lost some good rowers last season. Texas is still the favorite.
Hope we win all four and I eat my words!
In case there was any doubt, it's now official. https://gostanford.com/news/2025/02/25/bernard-muir-to-step-down-as-director-of-stanford-athletics?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=Commpost-ath_2025-02-25_1A2B4C&utm_campaign=sdother_otherpd_otherp__
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - gailtate - 02-25-2025
Best line so far: He couldn't think of five things he did last week so he quit.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - needle - 02-25-2025
I don't want it to get lost: we (the vast majority of fans, anyway) really don't know why Muir is resigning now.
Many, many possibilites. There is some online chatter that he has another AD job lined up.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - chrisk - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 01:53 PM)cctop Wrote:(02-25-2025, 12:58 PM)paloalto Wrote: To say some other AD would have gotten Stanford into the B1G or the SEC, give me a break.
Yes but Stanford might have been more attractive to the B1G if a proactive AD had stepped in sooner when it became obvious that football was declining.
It's hard to imagine Stanford wouldn't have gotten (or been able to negotiate) a B1G invite if the Pac-12 had collapsed in 2018 instead of 2023.
The Big 10 is having indigestion with 18 teams. I don't see any way that FOX would go for 20. And the weather would be less attractive for fall and spring sports.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - 82lsju - 02-25-2025
it is official
https://gostanford.com/news/2025/02/25/bernard-muir-to-step-down-as-director-of-stanford-athletics
Quote:After nearly 13 years leading one of the most successful intercollegiate athletic departments in the country, Bernard Muir has announced his intention to step down as director of Stanford Athletics at the end of this academic year.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - fullmetal - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 03:21 PM)Jamesy Wrote: Women's rowing lost some good rowers last season. Texas is still the favorite.Women's rowing graduated two rowers from their varsity eight, but they'll get back one rower who stopped out for a year to compete at the Olympics. Texas returns only two rowers from their varsity eight (the rest were 5th yrs/grad students and seniors), so they're not my favorite this year. Aside from Stanford, I'd watch out for Princeton, who had the most juniors in their varsity from last year's lineup and lost nobody from their top boat.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - BostonCard - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 01:53 PM)cctop Wrote:(02-25-2025, 12:58 PM)paloalto Wrote: To say some other AD would have gotten Stanford into the B1G or the SEC, give me a break.
Yes but Stanford might have been more attractive to the B1G if a proactive AD had stepped in sooner when it became obvious that football was declining.
It's hard to imagine Stanford wouldn't have gotten (or been able to negotiate) a B1G invite if the Pac-12 had collapsed in 2018 instead of 2023.
When was this supposed to have happened? Even in 2015 at the height of our football power, the Big Ten would not have taken us because it wouldn’t have made sense. I think our only hope would have been to go as USC’s partner but by then we were well on our way to irrelevance.
TV was driving this, and even with a good football team Stanford is not that attractive to TV.
BC
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - Mick - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 04:03 PM)needle Wrote: I don't want it to get lost: we (the vast majority of fans, anyway) really don't know why Muir is resigning now.
Many, many possibilites. There is some online chatter that he has another AD job lined up.
Bernard Muir's alma mater is Brown. Their AD, Jack Hayes, has recently resigned. Maybe he's heading to Brown. The job would be a lot easier, far less pressure.
Brown athletics director Hayes stepping down | WPRI.com
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - cardcrimson - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 03:52 PM)gailtate Wrote: Best line so far: He couldn't think of five things he did last week so he quit.Someone is stealing my material I posted on the Rivals site. . . .
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - Canalejas - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 12:23 PM)2006alum Wrote: we tied (ourselves) for the most national championships in a single season (6) in 2018-19, which was right during the peak of Muir's tenure
And in 2019-20, Stanford brought home 3 NCAA team titles (women's soccer, women's volleyball, men's water polo) in the fall before everything shut down for Covid. Chances are good it would have been another 4 title year with men's gymnastics. And who knows, maybe even more.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - PalmTree - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 04:24 PM)82lsju Wrote: it is official
https://gostanford.com/news/2025/02/25/bernard-muir-to-step-down-as-director-of-stanford-athletics
Quote:After nearly 13 years leading one of the most successful intercollegiate athletic departments in the country, Bernard Muir has announced his intention to step down as director of Stanford Athletics at the end of this academic year.
The 2024-25 academic year actually includes summer quarter, which ends September 11. Any chance he really intends to step down after spring quarter, which ends June 19? Just askin' for "a friend"......
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - 82lsju - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 07:36 PM)PalmTree Wrote:(02-25-2025, 04:24 PM)82lsju Wrote: it is official
https://gostanford.com/news/2025/02/25/bernard-muir-to-step-down-as-director-of-stanford-athletics
Quote:After nearly 13 years leading one of the most successful intercollegiate athletic departments in the country, Bernard Muir has announced his intention to step down as director of Stanford Athletics at the end of this academic year.
The 2024-25 academic year actually includes summer quarter, which ends September 11. Any chance he really intends to step down after spring quarter, which ends June 19? Just askin' for "a friend"......
well I would be surprised if he was actually working much once the interim AD is named other than in an "advisory capacity". This seems to me more like a move to allow him to get paid through the end of the academic year (either June or Sept) which might make any severance/termination terms less expensive for Stanford. It could also give him a more graceful offramp to his next gig. I would be surprised if he had any real decision making authority after today.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - chrisk - 02-25-2025
Daily interview with Andrew Luck
https://stanforddaily.com/2025/02/23/if-one-person-can-save-stanford-football-its-andrew-luck/
Luck is working with Sam Fisher ’14 MBA ’19, who was named the assistant general manager for the Stanford football program in January. Fisher is evaluating high school and college prospects and working to build strategy.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - Snorlax94 - 02-25-2025
(02-24-2025, 11:00 PM)PVTree Wrote: As an FYI, I heard from someone within DAPER that it's not all sunshine and rainbows with AL. I was told that he's not listening to the experienced people and relying on advice from football buddies without any sports management experience.I know that your overall statement addresses this point, but I can’t help pointing out the irony of the line:
“Andrew Luck is not listening to the experienced people.”
On top of his football knowledge and student athlete experience, his father was an AD, so he grew up getting an insider’s perspective on the financial/fundraising/hiring/managing/political aspects.
Maybe the “experienced people” should be listening to him.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - Jamesy - 02-25-2025
(02-25-2025, 04:03 PM)needle Wrote: I don't want it to get lost: we (the vast majority of fans, anyway) really don't know why Muir is resigning now.
Many, many possibilites. There is some online chatter that he has another AD job lined up.
If he had another job lined up, why would he stay on until the end of the academic year? And if it's because that job isn't opening up until then, why announce now?
(02-25-2025, 04:47 PM)fullmetal Wrote:(02-25-2025, 03:21 PM)Jamesy Wrote: Women's rowing lost some good rowers last season. Texas is still the favorite.Women's rowing graduated two rowers from their varsity eight, but they'll get back one rower who stopped out for a year to compete at the Olympics. Texas returns only two rowers from their varsity eight (the rest were 5th yrs/grad students and seniors), so they're not my favorite this year. Aside from Stanford, I'd watch out for Princeton, who had the most juniors in their varsity from last year's lineup and lost nobody from their top boat.
Thanks. I didn't dig into the UT or Princeton lineups and forgot about Celia coming back.
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - StanUSwagU - 02-25-2025
I know very few on this board are likely to agree with me, but in my opinion, we need to 'Aim Really High Profile' for our next AD
(1) Offer a Top Dollar contract that could entice/lure the 'Best ADs' in the profession like a 7yr $70 Million Dollar Contract !
Then Among the most important characteristics/qualifications for the next AD (in my opinion) are:
(1) Been the AD of a Power4 University whose Football Program has been a perennial Top25 program or Was a Legendary College Football player or College Football Coach at a Power4 University who 'lived, ate, & breathed Football his whole Life !
or
(2) At some point Played or Coached or AD'd in the #1 Football Conference = SEC
So, look to lure any of these following Current ADs:
--Alabama AD = Greg Byrne
--Ole Miss AD = Keith Carter
--Georgia AD = John Brooks
or
Maybe consider these following people who have not been in the 'AD world' but are 'College Football icons' =
--Peyton Manning
--Steve Spurrier
--Steve Young
And then they (these 6 AD candidates) or the University can hire a regular 'AD Type person to be their assistant to tackle all the tedious procedural beaurocratic 'day to day' AD stuff' while these 6 AD candidates ensure 'Every stone is turned over to (A) 'Get a Top 10 DollarWise NIL collective' for Football & Mens Basketball & (B) March down to the Admissions office to force them to have the same Freshman-admissions & Transfer-Admissions as NotreDame & Duke for Football & Mens Basketball) These 6men will 'definitely depart from the staid old Stanford-Way' & will Ensure the best chance of Top25 Football & Top25 Mens Basketball !
RE: Bernard Muir to Resign - BostonCard - 02-26-2025
Are you offering to front the money?
BC