Harbaugh has his shot Saturday

Harbaugh has his shot Saturday - Printable Version

+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Harbaugh has his shot Saturday (/thread-22652.html)

Pages: 1 2

RE: Harbaugh has his shot Saturday - lex24 - 11-26-2021

(11-25-2021, 02:55 PM)teejers1 Wrote:
(11-25-2021, 01:54 PM)lex24 Wrote: Win and there is a good shot they make the NCS. Lose and it’s yet another failure against a top team.

Lex, your fixation on Harbaugh and crusade to denigrate his coaching is remarkable.
Do you think Michigan has much of a chance? tOSU is on fire right now, and they have been spectacular for the entirety of Harbaugh's tenure at Michigan. And they are 7.5 point favorites . . . at Michigan. I think it far more likely that tOSU wins by 10+ points than Michigan pulls the upset.

Still, Michigan under Harbaugh gets 10 wins, in a much tougher conference, and a NY Day bowl (again).
We're so far from that now it's not even funny.

You read an awful lot into two simple sentences. JH was not hired to go 9-3. It’s Michigan. His teams have not played well in key games. I think this is his best shot. And if they win (and take care of business in the Big 14 Championship game) I have to think they are in the NCS.

RE: Harbaugh has his shot Saturday - Goose - 11-26-2021

(11-26-2021, 10:20 AM)lex24 Wrote: You read an awful lot into two simple sentences. JH was not hired to go 9-3. It’s Michigan. His teams have not played well in key games. I think this is his best shot. And if they win (and take care of business in the Big 14 Championship game) I have to think they are in the NCS.

If they win out, I believe they are in for sure. An interesting question is what happens if they don't win? JH has been under pressure, but the question is: Who can Michigan find that will be better? IMHO it will be very difficult to hire somebody "better" and very easy to hire somebody who will be worse, especially this year with so many openings at elite (OK, self-proclaimed elite) programs. As unpalatable as it may seem, sticking with JH even if he loses is probably their best bet. Not sure Michigan alums will see it that way though.

RE: Harbaugh has his shot Saturday - Mick - 11-26-2021

(11-25-2021, 03:41 PM)Farm93 Wrote: Still, Michigan under Harbaugh gets 10 wins, in a much tougher conference, and a NY Day bowl (again).
We're so far from that now it's not even funny.

Harbaugh will probably fail yet again to take what was once one of the premier college football programs in the USA to a conference title.
Harbaugh's record, at Michigan, against top 10 teams is AWFUL.
He actually is winning at a rate below the historic winning percentage of the program.

That noted to compare success at Michigan by any coach to success at Stanford for any coach is not particularly meaningful.

One program struggles to find 50,000 to fill the seats even when the team sports a top 5 ranking.
The other program can put 100,000 people in the stands during a driving snow storm or when the opponent is a weak FCS team.
One team has 15 conference titles in its history (3 with the current coach) the other has 42 conference titles (0 with its current coach).
One team claims 2 national titles, the other claims 11 national titles.

That noted I am not sure what the fixation Harbaugh is all about here. He actually left Stanford. While he was here consistently complained about the very things that will keep other coaches away or drive them to find a better gig after their first 8+ win season.
[/quote]

Three thoughts:

1) Harbaugh has four 10 win seasons in his six full seasons. 9 and 8 wins in the other two.
2) Schembechler was pretty good against top 10 teams (16-22) and not so good in bowl games (5-12). Three of his four successors weren't as good as Harbaugh (Moeller, RichRod, Hoke) though Coach Lloyd Carr was better. I don't know that UMich is happy with Harbaugh, but i don't think they're unhappy enough to part ways.
3) It's amazing to attend a Michigan game. I've been to four, I think the lowest attendance was over 108,000. But then, they don't have professional football in that state (unless you count the hapless Detroit Lions, still winless, and with one postseason win in 63 years. So UMich is their alternative, a perennial winner. The highway signs in Michigan use the University of Michigan logo, for goodness sake. Point being that the interest in the program is a bit insane, though the UMich fans generally acknowledge it as such.

RE: Harbaugh has his shot Saturday - OutsiderFan - 11-27-2021

Well, Michigan ran the ball 41 times for 297 yards and held Ohio State to FGs in the red zone and 64 yards rushing.

That's how you win games 42-27.

Heard on the broadcast:

Harbaugh fired his whole defensive coaching staff last season. He replaced with a 34 yo DC from the Ravens, and no assistant coach on the staff is under 45. They are hungry and wanting to make a name for themselves. That's what you want. Jim Harbaugh has always done a great job trying to improve his coaching staff.

RE: Harbaugh has his shot Saturday - 2006alum - 11-27-2021

Congrats to Harbs. Great to see him get this albatross from around his neck. I don't think he was the right guy for Stanford over the long term, but I'll always be grateful for what he did for our program.

lex24 - lex24 - 11-27-2021

(11-27-2021, 01:51 PM)OutsiderFan Wrote: Well, Michigan ran the ball 41 times for 297 yards and held Ohio State to FGs in the red zone and 64 yards rushing.

That's how you win games 42-27.

Heard on the broadcast:

Harbaugh fired his whole defensive coaching staff last season. He replaced with a 34 yo DC from the Ravens, and no assistant coach on the staff is under 45. They are hungry and wanting to make a name for themselves. That's what you want. Jim Harbaugh has always done a great job trying to improve his coaching staff.

He went forward and backwards. The latter being a reference to returning to power football. What he does best. They slaughtered OSU at the LOS. On both sides of the ball. No substitute for that. Sigh…….

RE: lex24 - gailtate - 11-27-2021

(11-27-2021, 02:07 PM)lex24 Wrote:
(11-27-2021, 01:51 PM)OutsiderFan Wrote: Well, Michigan ran the ball 41 times for 297 yards and held Ohio State to FGs in the red zone and 64 yards rushing.

That's how you win games 42-27.

Heard on the broadcast:

Harbaugh fired his whole defensive coaching staff last season. He replaced with a 34 yo DC from the Ravens, and no assistant coach on the staff is under 45. They are hungry and wanting to make a name for themselves. That's what you want. Jim Harbaugh has always done a great job trying to improve his coaching staff.

He went forward and backwards. The latter being a reference to returning to power football. What he does best. They slaughtered OSU at the LOS. On both sides of the ball. No substitute for that. Sigh…….

Timing is everything.

RE: Harbaugh has his shot Saturday - teejers1 - 11-27-2021

(11-26-2021, 12:07 PM)Mick Wrote: Harbaugh will probably fail yet again to take what was once one of the premier college football programs in the USA to a conference title.
Harbaugh's record, at Michigan, against top 10 teams is AWFUL.
He actually is winning at a rate below the historic winning percentage of the program.

1. Harbaugh had misfortune of coaching in Ann Arbor at Peak TOSU (how many of those Top 10 losses are to the Buckeyes)?

2. Aside from tOSU, Michigan is clearly the next strongest program in the Big 10 (and we'll see if there is a new pecking order after today). The Ls against other good teams - Michigan State, most notably - were flukey. That blocked punt on last play of game? AYFKM? The last game between the two teams this year, Michigan was the better team.

3. BTW, Michigan program and fans at all-time high right now. Will be tough to come down and focus in conference title game against a very solid (at minimum) Wisconsin team (my prediction). I think Michigan rolls Iowa if they play them, regardless. We'll see . . .

Anyway, hard not to (a) be happy for MichiganFan today, and (b) compare that atmosphere to what we have on The Farm and not be sad.